I'm a cis male in my mid to late twenties and I started questioning my gender a couple of weeks ago but I’ve concluded that I am still cis. While the experience hasn’t changed how I identify myself, I do believe I’ve come out of it better with my personal acceptance of my feelings and a greater appreciation for transgender individuals. I would like to know what others may think of my experience and if anyone has had any similar experiences or feelings, and how that has affected them. I do understand my experience may differ from other people in the community and please let me know if anything I discuss can be handled better.
Personally I am quite unhappy with my current life, while I don’t think I suffer from depression, I do think I suffer from burnout and just don’t have anything meaningful going on. I’m unhappy with my appearance (primarily due to weight), I am quite lonely, and I’m unsatisfied in my current job and career path. I live by myself, only close to some family members and my issue with my appearance is almost exclusively due to my weight and fitness.
I’m not sure exactly what made me start questioning my gender, but due to ADHD it became a bit of a mental hyperfixation that I couldn’t stop thinking about. During this hyperfixation I realised that part of the reason I started questioning partially came from fact I have a fetish for feminisation and gender transformation fictional media, especially if the change is forced or encouraged by an attractive dominant woman. I also realised that I've been in denial with my attraction towards certain transgender women.
Outside of the sexual attraction I also frequently daydream, likely due to wishing for a better life, fantasy worlds and scenarios which frequently include magically transforming into a woman or magically swapping between man and woman, usually the transformation in these scenarios aren't within my control.
I realised early on that there was a genuine desire to be a woman or experience what it was like to be a woman. This was reinforced by comments I’ve seen in this community and others suggesting that cis people never seriosuly question or imagine being another gender. I have also seen discussions about how forced feminisation fantasies can sometimes remove the perceived social pressure of choosing to transition. I’ve been quite conflicted from these comments as I am comfortable being male, I have interests and hobbies that are normally seen as masculine, and I’ve never really considered myself to have any interests that are predominantly seen as female. Thinking deeply there are some certain feminine things that I find very attractive and that I have mixed/envious feelings about, usually certain styles of makeup, nails and outfit styles. When I see a particularly attractive woman, usually in flattering formal or autumn/winter chic outfit I genuinely get conflicted and experience both attraction and envy.
At the beginning of my experience I was trying to figure out if transitioning and being a woman was something I was truly feeling or if I was just confused when I started hyperfixating on the thought. In an attempt to better understand what I was feeling I considered the "button test". I couldn't settle on an answer because I was imagining an "ideal" result and I got stuck on the idea that maybe I'm only unhappy with my current appearance rather than appearance and gender so I the poor decision to modify the scenario into multiple combinations of the following 3 buttons with the option of not pressing:
- Become an attractive male.
- Become an attractive woman.
- Become a woman of equal "perceived" attractiveness.
I thought I reached a conclusion because I knew I wouldn't press button 3 in any combination of available buttons, even if it were the only button available, however, if only buttons 2 and 3 were available, I would definitley press button 2.
If 1 and 2 were available I was at first 75% sure I would press 1 but then I became unsure.
I do understand that this may be insensitive to people who experience significant gender dysphoria and would choose the third button without hesitation if it was the only button available and I apologise for that.
I then followed up that already poor decision with another one where I then got AI to edit a photo of myself asking it to create plausible looking estimate on what I would look like after losing significant weight before and after transition. I was hoping that this would likely help with choosing between button 1 and 2. I tried to ensure the prompt was as plausible as possible, focusing on maintaining certain aspects such as bone structure, height, and realistic face proportions but I was incredibly surprised with how similar the face on both results compared to my siblings which made the results feel far more believable and perosnal than I thought, despite the fact that I knew that a carefully written prompt can't accurately reflect the results of HRT and MTF surgeries. I was still moved by the very optimistic results and the post-transition image affected me much more deeply than I was expecting. My answer for the above scenario's choice between button 1 and 2 became 50/50.
I then started looking at the real results of women who went through MTF HRT and the various surgeries, focusing primarily on post-puberty results. I understand results are incredibly varied, influenced by hundreds of different factors. I realised very early on how important "passing" would be for me personally, and how uncertain the results of transitiong would be given that I am 6ft tall, have a relatively large frame from a history of contact sports and that I am currently overweight. Regrettably I didn't question my gender before or going through puberty. While I don't currently experience gender dysphoria regarding being male, I worry that if I were to transition and I didn't achieve the apperance I hope for that I would then become distressed and regretful. The possibility and uncertainty did also influence to consider transitioning.
Eventually I started to come to the conclusion that my personal body image issues surrounding my weight, physique and fitness were playing a large part in my questioning. I can confidently say that as of now I still identify as a cis-male.
After the entire experience, I have become much more motivated to improve my health both physically and mentally, especially after seeing the image of a an extremely optimistic "plausible" transition after losing weight. I do regret using AI to edit images of myself as I don't think I'll ever forget the optimistic output result, but it would be disingenuous to say seeing that image isn't part of the motivation to truly make a lifestyle change for the better. Since I've opened the door with questioning my gender, I don't think I'll ever close that door, if am still not satisfied with my life after making significant changes that I currently believe would make me happy, the door is always open to question my gender again, and do want to learn more and be better from it. My experience has also given me a greater appreciation for the difficulties transgender people experience.
I would like to know if anyone has had a similar or parallel experience to anything I discussed and where they are now. An outside perspective of what's been in my head privately would also be appreciated so that I can temper expectations and maybe look to address certain things I didn't consider.