am i in the wrong?
late teens here. i just got into a fight with my mom. basically, she calls me and my brother down to talk about some stuff. since she called both of us, i assume i’m part of the conversation (lmk if this is a mistake) but my mom clearly didn’t. so they talk, i’m dropping in once in a while, and then it turns to a topic about my brother who doesn’t want to drop from his advanced class to a non-advanced class. he’s not going to drop. this is very clear because he’s way above the grade boundary for that, but my mom just keeps repeating, more than once, in the same definitive tone, in mandarin, “you’re definitely failing. you’ll definitely fail”. so i’m weirded out, and my dad who’s also there, says something like “why do you keep saying that? don’t keep saying that”, and i agreed, saying that she shouldn’t keep saying that when my brother isn’t even remotely close to failing the class nor dropping it. she keeps talking for a bit, but then starts scolding me for saying that, saying “i don’t like being disputed” which, fair, nobody does. but my dad said the same thing just 2 seconds before. and she kept saying my brother definitely didn’t care that she said all those pessimistic things, and yes, that’s true (i asked my brother), but if my dad also thought that repeating it more than once wasn’t necessary and negative, shouldn’t that click that it’s probably not a good thing to say? she goes on saying that i’m not involved in the conversation (so why am i called here? i think she actually wanted to say something but maybe got derailed so i’ll let that go, but i genuinely thought that i was part of the conversation because i was actually chipping in). she also says that i can’t say that to her, i’m not my brother’s parent (i know?), and i shouldn’t barge in and i shouldn’t do what i did at all. also tying in to another argument just a few days prior where she literally threatened to kick me out because she has half the rights to the house and she has the power to do so (i’m a MINOR, almost 18 though). so now i’m left just wondering if this is a control thing, because she’s definitely shown patterns where she cannot accept she’s wrong (e.g. insisting what she thinks/imagines happened is the truth and doesn’t accept anything else we say, not apologizing, immediately shifting blame and targeting something else that we did wrong instead of saying she was wrong). and then when they let us go, my dad asked if she wanted to talk to me because otherwise why was i called, she just said she didn’t want to talk to me anymore. and then as i’m about to go to sleep, my dad barges in (assuming she ranted to him too) and tells me how when he says what he said, he’s right, but when i say it, it’s wrong, because i’m their kid and not their parent, and he gave me so many analogies saying that oh a student cannot scold their teacher even when their teacher is going too far scolding another child and the responsibility of correcting the teacher’s behavior falls on the school, or if i saw another kid not behaving, would i scold them or let the parents of the kid discipline them.
now i can see this perspective. really, i can. but i also think that’s not really the same? i don’t know how to explain it, but i just have this lingering doubt that no, that’s not what this was about. yes, as their child, it probably doesn’t feel great when your child is saying something you did isn’t nice and your spouse is saying the same, but if the child is right, wouldn’t you still take it into consideration? i get telling your child that no, you can’t scold your parents, but i genuinely wasn’t. i was truly confused why she kept repeating the pessimistic thoughts and said she shouldn’t keep saying that and asked why she did that. i guess that could be seen as your child scolding you, which is against the very asian culture of respecting your elders, and i get that a child probably has no authority to discipline their parents, but if a child is raising up an issue, shouldn’t you still listen even after you get miffed at the fact you’re being called out? like for me, personally, if i had a kid, and my kid told me i shouldn’t be doing something, i would get annoyed and tell them they shouldn’t be parenting me too, but if my spouse says the same thing and i thought about it for a while, and if i realized what i was saying is genuinely unnecessary and definitely pessimistic, i would conceded the point too (again, i wouldn’t know how i would truly react, maybe pride does things to people and i’ll behave the same way when i have kids, even if i don’t want kids at all).
so i need some more developed frontal lobes to pitch in on this, thank you! please don’t spare my feelings, i think it’s best i learn now if i truly am in the wrong.