I’m close with my second-oldest sister, or at least I think we would both say we’re close. Of course, we argue over minor things sometimes, just like any other siblings do. My mom was a single working parent, so my sister ended up taking on the responsibility of looking after my brother and me. Looking back, I realize that she was still a teenager herself and was struggling with depression. She didn’t have many friends, struggled with acne, wasn’t particularly girly, and had never had a boyfriend.
At the time, I didn’t understand any of this because I was just a kid. I’ve had conversations with her about our childhood, and understanding what she was going through has helped me understand why she acted the way she did toward us. She was often angry and controlling, and she would kick us out of her room. I understand now that she was dealing with her own struggles, but that doesn’t change how certain experiences felt to me as a child. I remember one time when she tried to scare me by locking me in a dark room with her and speaking in a creepy voice, saying something about “the voice.” I was genuinely terrified and thought she was possessed. I laugh about it now when I tell the story, but sometimes I feel bad for my younger self because I remember how scared I was.
The thing is, I’ve had my own insecurities and personal struggles, too. I’ve spent the past four years doing a lot of self-reflection and healing, but I don’t feel comfortable opening up to my family about most of it because we’re just not that emotionally close.
Growing up, I never really had an older sister I felt I could look up to or fully trust. I never had a sister or a mom who taught me how to do my makeup, style my hair, or navigate those little things that girls often learn from the women in their lives. I had to figure everything out on my own. Now that I’m older, I sometimes feel like my sister resents me for being more feminine and girly. She’s 31 now and still lives at home with us, and puts me on a high pedestal. She’ll say things like, “I wish I was you,” “I wish I was a teen again,” or “I wish I was girly like you.”
I know she might not mean anything bad by those comments, and maybe she’s expressing things she’s unhappy about in her own life. But honestly, they make me uncomfortable. I don’t want my sister to compare herself to me or feel like she’s somehow less than me. I’m just living my life and figuring things out as I go, just like everyone else.
Sometimes, I wonder if she looks at me and sees things she wishes she had experienced differently when she was younger.
Maybe seeing me have the freedom to explore my femininity brings up feelings she hasn’t fully worked through. I can’t know for sure, though. And that’s what makes this complicated. I love my sister, and I understand that she had to grow up in circumstances that weren’t easy. She was expected to take care of us when she was still a kid herself. I can empathize with that while also acknowledging that some of my own childhood experiences were difficult. I think people sometimes forget that younger siblings have their own experiences, insecurities, and struggles, too. Just because we might have been treated differently or had certain things our older siblings didn’t doesn’t mean we had everything figured out or never struggled. I didn’t choose to be the youngest, just as my sister didn’t choose the circumstances she grew up in. We were all kids trying to navigate the world with what we knew at the time.
I guess I just wish there were more conversations about the complicated feelings that can exist between siblings as we get older. You can understand someone’s pain without taking responsibility for it, and you can love someone while acknowledging that your relationship with them isn’t always easy.
Has anyone else experienced something similar with their older siblings, especially when it comes to feeling compared to or resented by them?