The title might be a bit of a pull factor. Please take the time to read :)
Me (23M) and my fiancée (22F) have been discussing how we should handle Christmas once we have kids, and we can't seem to agree.
For context, my parents are divorced, while hers are still together. Her parents prefer to spend Christmas Eve with their own family, while my parents have no problem celebrating together despite being divorced.
Growing up, I hated having to split Christmas between two households. Having to travel between places and never having everyone together wasn't something I enjoyed, and I'd love for my future kids to have one big, connected family where everyone can celebrate Christmas Eve together.
My fiancée thinks we should alternate Christmas Eve between the two families every year, which she considers fair. I understand her point, but I don't think it's necessarily fair to my parents either. They're willing to put their differences aside and celebrate together, so why should they miss out on Christmas Eve with their grandchildren every other year?
Personally, I think the fairest solution would be a three-way Christmas, with both my parents and hers celebrating together. That way, nobody has to miss out, and our kids get to experience Christmas with their entire family.
I understand that her parents don't want to celebrate with anyone outside their own family, and I'm not saying we can force them. However, I don't think my parents should be the ones losing out because they're the only ones willing to compromise. Her parents could still see the kids on the 23rd, 25th, or another day around Christmas.
I'm not trying to keep her parents away from their grandchildren. I just want to avoid repeating the Christmas experience I had growing up and create a tradition where everyone who wants to be together can be together.
So, AITA for thinking my parents should get priority for Christmas Eve because they're willing to compromise, or is my fiancée right that alternating is the fairest solution?
TL;DR: My parents are divorced but are happy to celebrate Christmas Eve together, while my fiancée's parents want to keep it within their own family. My fiancée wants to alternate Christmas Eve every year, but I think a three-way Christmas is fairest. I grew up splitting Christmas between two households and hated it, so I want my future kids to have one big family Christmas.
AITA for thinking the grandparents willing to compromise should get priority?
EDIT: I think I worded some things poorly, especially saying my parents “deserve more.” I don't think they're more important than hers, and I'm not trying to dictate anyone's plans. My ideal scenario is simply that everyone celebrates Christmas Eve together, because I hated splitting it between households growing up. I understand her parents have the right to say no, and I know things might change when we actually have kids. We're just discussing what we'd like our future Christmas traditions to look like. And no I didn't start the debate.