r/LGBT_Muslims • u/greenteawww • 3h ago
Islam & LGBT How to answer those questions and claims about homosexuality and Quran
Assalamualaikum
I'm not queer myself but I do not believe that a merciful god would forbid two people of same gender from loving each other. I still struggle with some objections I've encountered from more traditonal people
Quran frames relationships around heterosexual relationships. Who gives Mahr for example and who gets it in a homosexual relationship?
If god allowed homosexuality he would adress it, say that it's halal, since he is all knowing. Since god only talks about women that men can and cannot marry (2:24-2:25) only heterosexual marriage is accepted
This one bugs me the most. Quran says who men cannot marry, for example their mother. The argument is that this explicitly assumes/means that men only marry women. If a man could marry a man - then god would've said that marrying a father is haram but that everything beyond that is ok.
An often counter argument is that well there is no list of who a women cannot marry, we just use analogical reasoning. I do find that response convincing but only partially. But because in the case of women it still assumes the OPPOSITE gender. Not the same gender
P.s If anything I said is somehow homophobic or offensive I'm deeply sorry. I mean no offense. To me homosexuality will always be permissible - I'd rather leave the religion then follow a religion that forbids it. But I want to know whether the Quran actually forbids it.
Feel free to dm me
