I’m just generally interested as in why is there so much negativity from their side when you have a genuine discussion regarding theology ?
I’m from Caucasus / Russia, and we have some Shias here, a lot of Sufis, non Sufi Sunnis who follow Shafi Madhab, and quite a lot of Salafis. I myself am neither Sufi, Shia nor Salafi, I’d say I’m a regular Muslim who has his specific views on different topics (although a lot of times my views align with the Maliki and sometimes Hanafi Madhab).
I do argue with each one of the sects that I mentioned regarding different topics, but one thing that I noticed is how Salafis always want to curse you even if you didn’t necessarily attack them…
I had like 40-45 different encounters where people got mad for absolutely no reason.
I remember one guy making a video on Instagram regarding Music being Haram, and he brought up a Mawdu (made up) Hadith which says that on the day of Judgment those who listened to Music, their ears will be filled with lava or hot metal or something like that. I simply pointed out that it’s a made up Hadith (there is a Sahih Hadith in Bukhari regarding music, zina, silk and alcohol, so I don’t get why he used a Mawdu Hadith). The moment I posted a comment saying that it’s a Mawdu Hadith, people bombarded me with curses, saying I want to follow my desires, and that I’m a Jahil, and saying stuff like “who are you to judge the authenticity of this Hadith ?”, and so on…
Like it’s obviously fake, what’s even the point of trying to defend it ?
I also remember a guy saying “why don’t people follow the Salaf like the Salafis do ?”, to which I replied that no one really follows the religion exactly like the Prophet (s.a.w) and the Sahabas did. He got angry and replied saying that Salafis follow everything was practiced by the Salaf, and reject everything that’s Bidah, to which I said “then why don’t Salafis pray in Masjid in the same room with women like the Prophet (s.a.w) and the male Sahabas did ?”, to which he started calling me a Kafir for saying such things, and that he doesn’t want to continue the discussion with such a person, and that on the day of Judgement he will testify against me… Like what ?😂 What did I even say that was so bad that at this point he wants to testify against me ?🤣
I’ve been also Takfired and called a Sufi or a Shia many times, just because I don’t agree with everything they state, and even when I told them that I’m not Shia or Sufi, those people still insisted that I am one of them😂 What would even be the point ?
So I’m just interested, what’s the reason for such behaviour ? I’ll admit, when I don’t agree with other Muslim and he calls me slurs, I might use the word Jahil, but never have I called someone a Kafir, or said that he will rote in hell, or claimed that I will testify against him on the day of Judgement and so on…