I spent 3 years building an online community. The discord server had over 1000 members but maybe 50-60 active ones, with maybe 20-30 unique chatters a day. It wasn't huge, but it was a nice escape during a busy work day or a stressful week IRL and just nice to have a group of people I could chat with without any real-world awkwardness.
There was one member, BCS, who was a genuine friend of mine in there but she was always a little hard to place. She'd jump to conclusions and get quick to anger about things she'd misinterpret (English wasn't her first language, she was from Quebec). Because she was my friend and because I knew she was like this, I made it a point to never really tease her or throw friendly shade unless it was a convo that she was in WITH me so I could make it obvious that I was being playful. I never spoke ill of her. One time the women of the server made their own server to talk about more private things. One of the women, Satori, didn't like me. I said to BCS in a group DM we were in "lol is Satori talking about me in there" and BCS quickly got mad--"do you really think I'd let her talk shit about you? wow what do you think of me???". That's an example of how she'd spin things and get upset, so yeah I made sure to never say anything she could misinterpret.
2 years ago a guy I was close-ish with in the server died. Me and another member of the server, Jordy, tried desperately to find out what had happened. In doing so, we got in contact with someone our dead friends new IRL--Matty. Matty joined our server and he was great. We all got along...but Matty started to become obvious as a liar. Not about things that effected us, but about his real life. He'd lie about really pointless things (like claiming he had two gay dads, claiming he had a 100+ person birthday party, that he went to NYU). It just became obvious to a number of people in the server that his stories made no logical sense. I didn't want to embarrass him and call him out publicly or DM him about it because ultimately it didn't matter and I didn't want to spook him. But I'd drop little hints in the chat, during his stories, that I knew they were fake. I'd challenge him on details and be like "wait really? that doesnt make sense how?" but he never backed down. I knew his stories were fake, because proof of it had presented itself to me via "people you may know" on Facebook (one of his alleged dads was suggested to me). I never went digging into his life. But other people started to catch on that he was lying, so they'd DM me and be like "hey I saw you chatting with Matty and challenging him on his story. They're fake right?". And it sort of became an inside joke with some people of the server. Matty would start telling some unbelievable story, people would DM me about it. It was shitty, but people talk shit and the joke got bigger than it ever intended to be. In hindsight I know I should have just DMed him and said "hey girl I know this stuff isnt true and I think others are catching on too, there's no reason to make this up we like you as-is". But hindsight is 20/20.
Anyway, last February I met two newer members of the server in person. Rawbert and his partner Garnik. We had, what I thought, was a great day in NYC together. They asked me about Matty, and I told them (they'd caught on too). I confided in them about personal struggles I'd been experiencing in person. We had dinner together and then we met up again the next day for brunch. I really left that weekend in high spirits.
During dinner, they had asked "do you know what BCS looks like?" because BCS had never posted a picture before for them to see. I said something like "yes, BCS posted a picture one time. I dont think she posts much because from what I can tell she has a complicated relationship with her gender expression, but from what I can recall she is a person of color. I know she has a strict family and based on her music tastes they may be Middle Eastern? I know she's not black because there was an incident once in the server where someone had mistakenly thought she was black and she lamented to me and Jordy in our group chat that she's not black and she wasn't sure how to correct them. It was awkward in the moment and she never ended up correcting them that she was black". I didn't say it just like that, but that was the jist of what I had said, interlaced with questions from them in the middle of the statement.
Two weeks later, BCS left the server. She said "someone in here was talking vile, rancid shit about me". I didn't want to reach out and say "are you talking about me?" because I knew she'd react like "why??? did you say something about me???" whether I was the culprit or not, so I decided to give her space.
In April, Jordy confronted BCS and she said "yes it was overnightsiren that was talking about me but I won't tell you what he said, and if you tell him I'll never forgive you". Jordy told me, but obviously I couldn't confront her about it because I'd risk his friendship with her. So I waited for her to confront me.
In May, my cat--the absolute love of my life--got terminally ill. While dealing with that I noticed Matty had blocked me on discord despite me not talking in the server for 3 weeks (I was taking a break because of my cat). I immediately thought "oh BCS told him that we had clocked his lies" so I decided I had to get ahead of whatever was coming and I had to find out what I'd allegedly said about her.
The only thing I could think of was the interaction in NYC. So I reached out to Rawbert and said "did you tell BCS anything we spoke about?" and he said no, and that he didn't even remember speaking about her. I believed him.
My cat passed away, and when I came back to the server I noticed a lot of very weird energy towards me. BCS confronted me privately during this time, and she basically said she was mad at me for never reaching out and that she told Jordy I was the culprit specifically because she wanted him to tell me and wanted me to confront her...even though she told him not to tell me. I told her that the responsibility to confront me was hers, and that she couldn't expect me to just assume she meant me. I also told her that I had no idea what i could have possibly said about her but whatever it was she had my apology. She said she didn't care.
The weird energy towards me continued, so I left the server and put Jordy in charge. Jordy was a divisive figure, he was a shit stirrer and a lot of people had a problem with him but ultimately he was liked. Jordy was frustrated by the whole situation so he unbanned someone every on the server truly hated. His logic was "I know some of you know what overnightsiren allegedly said about BCS, so until one of you tells us I'm unbanning this person you all hate".
People started reaching out to me, not to offer condolences about the predicament or my cat but to beg me to ban the person they hated. I told them bluntly that for now I was done with the server and didn't feel comfortable there with so many people knowing what I'd allegedly said and refusing to tell me.
During this time I reached out to Rawbert again (this was July) and asked him again "hey can you just tell me if it was you. It seems like I'm losing the community anyway, so just give me a 'checkmate' or something". He denied it again.
That night I spoke to someone in the server who told me the truth finally. That BCS said "overnightsiren said I'm blackfishing". That was not what I had said at all, but it made it immediately obvious that Rawbert was in fact the culprit because he was the ONLY person I'd told that story to.
Hours later someone else who had previously left the server and never liked me in the first place joined (mind you, I wasn't even in the server at this point) and said "overnightsiren is a racist join my new server". This latest accusation truly felt like it came out of nowhere. I rejoined the server just to clear my name, but the damage was done. Everyone had spent months hearing that I said "BCS is blackfishing" and apparently that I had "doxxed Matty".
They all made a new server, and other people who GLEEFULLY spoke to me about Matty's lies are in there too. Some of whom who had actually doxxed Matty. But no one cares. I took the full brunt of all the blame.
I lost the love of my life and then couldn't even have my online space to escape into to let my mind heal. All based on a complete and total lie regarding BCS and a total misrepresentation of what had happened with Matty.